FD Short Shifters: An Endangered Species
#1
Thread Starter
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 30,580
Likes: 567
From: FL-->NJ/NYC again!
FD Short Shifters: An Endangered Species
I just ordered a Mazdatrix short shifter for my Black R1, and it appears I scored one of the last new ones in the country. Mazdatrix has them listed as 'No Longer Available' and Ari over at RP happened to have a single unit in stock.
Soooooo, let's see here:
C's: NLA
B&M: NLA
Mazdaspeed: NLA
Mazdatrix: NLA
So we're left with either the RE-Amemiya (do not like, just a shorter height shifter with stock throw) or the Pettit. I remember reading that the Pettit has a similar issue, although I haven't had my hands on one in a long time. I'm not going to mention the cheapo/no name/ebay shifters.
Not a great situation for those looking to move away from the OEM shift linkage......
Silver lining to the clowd, Ari tells me that RP has most of the parts already made to construct Mazdaspeed replicas. Being that there aren't many options out there, he's looking into pushing forward with production
Soooooo, let's see here:
C's: NLA
B&M: NLA
Mazdaspeed: NLA
Mazdatrix: NLA
So we're left with either the RE-Amemiya (do not like, just a shorter height shifter with stock throw) or the Pettit. I remember reading that the Pettit has a similar issue, although I haven't had my hands on one in a long time. I'm not going to mention the cheapo/no name/ebay shifters.
Not a great situation for those looking to move away from the OEM shift linkage......
Silver lining to the clowd, Ari tells me that RP has most of the parts already made to construct Mazdaspeed replicas. Being that there aren't many options out there, he's looking into pushing forward with production
#2
Good riddance. I've yet to drive a car with a short shifter that was worth a damn.
Fresh OEM bushings on the OEM shift lever with a good, heavy shift **** and that's all you need.
Dale
Fresh OEM bushings on the OEM shift lever with a good, heavy shift **** and that's all you need.
Dale
#3
Thread Starter
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 30,580
Likes: 567
From: FL-->NJ/NYC again!
Different strokes for different folks, Tree....
I currently own two FDs with OEM shift pieces. One has 12k miles on it and feels as good as any I've yet to try, and another is a higher mileage FD but with all new bushings. While it's not horrible, I definitely prefer the feel of say, a C's unit to it
I currently own two FDs with OEM shift pieces. One has 12k miles on it and feels as good as any I've yet to try, and another is a higher mileage FD but with all new bushings. While it's not horrible, I definitely prefer the feel of say, a C's unit to it
#4
I have a B&M replica from Rx7store. Personally, I really like it. Shifts are smooth and exact. I have heard some say they didn't like the clicking feel of the engagement, but I have had no issues. For $80, it was a definite win.
#6
B&M here. Came with my first fd. When I got my 94 previous owner had a Re-A shifter and it was one of the first things I swapped from the old car, that and my mazdaspeed shift ****. Afterwards I was like "ok, there we go."
Like you said, different strokes. I drove my brother-in-law's Lancer with a stock shift and I was thinking, wow this is like driving an 18 wheeler. lol
Like you said, different strokes. I drove my brother-in-law's Lancer with a stock shift and I was thinking, wow this is like driving an 18 wheeler. lol
Trending Topics
#8
I think I need to try another shorty, I've never driven with the stock shifter. I'm not sure what mine is since it had no labeling, looks maybe an eBay B&M clone.
It can be seen here:
https://www.rx7club.com/3rd-generati...9/#post9945242
I've been thinking about changing for a while. It's very accurate, but a not smooth enough for my liking. Sometimes I have trouble getting into 2nd, sometimes it's smooth as butter. For whatever reason I've missed upshifting to 5th and accidently going into 3rd instead. I think I'm ready to start trying out some other shifters. Love the accuracy, but the notchiness is a bit annoying.
It can be seen here:
https://www.rx7club.com/3rd-generati...9/#post9945242
I've been thinking about changing for a while. It's very accurate, but a not smooth enough for my liking. Sometimes I have trouble getting into 2nd, sometimes it's smooth as butter. For whatever reason I've missed upshifting to 5th and accidently going into 3rd instead. I think I'm ready to start trying out some other shifters. Love the accuracy, but the notchiness is a bit annoying.
#9
I've been thinking about changing for a while. It's very accurate, but a not smooth enough for my liking. Sometimes I have trouble getting into 2nd, sometimes it's smooth as butter. For whatever reason I've missed upshifting to 5th and accidently going into 3rd instead. I think I'm ready to start trying out some other shifters. Love the accuracy, but the notchiness is a bit annoying.
#10
Yup, the oil is brand new Redline. Granted, this was after a fresh AT to MT swap, but I've put about 500-800 miles on it since then. Lot's of traffic and shifting up and down. It's not as clunking as it was new which was to be expected, but it's still notchy.
#11
Old school Pettit version here. Works great, very smooth and much better than the stock unit IMO. Have heard the new Pettit ones are not good though but that is from here on the forum not in person.
Dale you can drive my car to test the shifter out
Dale you can drive my car to test the shifter out
#12
#15
#16
I have a C's short shifter and I love it.... I have also heard that the "NEW" Pettit shifter is just a new shifter that is cut down... can't confirm though...
Also, both my sons have B&M replica's in their FD's and they have had NO issues with them...
L8R
Also, both my sons have B&M replica's in their FD's and they have had NO issues with them...
L8R
#17
Short Shifter
I did this before seeing Rob's site and was looking for a pic on google for Sparco and it came-up...probably the most cots-effective mod I have ever done...I have not even grinded mine !
I did this before seeing Rob's site and was looking for a pic on google for Sparco and it came-up...probably the most cots-effective mod I have ever done...I have not even grinded mine !
#18
https://www.rx7club.com/3rd-generati...rience-371203/
I would suggest changing out the oil to Neo or Amsoil GL-4.
#19
There are a ton of threads that compare Redline to other oils. The general review is that Redline causes notchiness. Here's a good read:
https://www.rx7club.com/3rd-generati...rience-371203/
I would suggest changing out the oil to Neo or Amsoil GL-4.
https://www.rx7club.com/3rd-generati...rience-371203/
I would suggest changing out the oil to Neo or Amsoil GL-4.
#20
I have a B&M replica but my mechanic convinced me not to use it cause according to his experience most cause problems in the long run and very notchy overall. Most short shifter threads in this forum agree. Having said that, I think the one in my MR2 Turbo was ok. I vaguely remember a difficulty putting in first gear though....
#21
I used to have a Mazdatrix SS in my previous FD (with the same transmission I'm using now). While it did not have the vibration issue they warn about on their site, it was too notchy. A stock shifter with all new bushings is just buttery smooth. Hard to beat the OEM feel imo, and the throw is already fairly short.
B&M Replicas suck ***. Had one in my current FD when I bought it.
#23
Which shoft shifters have you tried? I'm curious as to why you don't like them. While I see the appeal of the smoothness of the stock FD shifter, I have to admit, after getting used to the short throws and tighter feeling of engagement, I can't go back.
#24
plus i just ordered the Garfinkle engine brace which is also supposed to make shifting feel better so it should only get better from here
i think what Dale might be saying is the visibility of being in gear?? i really had to get used to not seeing the **** thrown in a direction anymore when i first started with my short shift...scared the hell out of me a couple times at passing glances while driving loll
#25
Eats, Sleeps, Dreams Rotary
iTrader: (19)
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 4,467
Likes: 1,455
From: West Coast
I'm 100% stoked on the Amemiya shifter that's been in my car for almost 8 years.