Megasquirt question.
#1
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 97
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Megasquirt question.
I searched but all the results were listed in the first gen forum so that did me no good. I have an 87 TII, essentially stock. Im starting to mod the car and i see kits for the megasquirt for like 300$ or so. Seems cheaper than some of the other management systems. My questions are; how easy is this to install and get running on your car, does it work for TII or only n/a, and lastly will it remove any functions i need/like on the car. oh, its a v2.2 and yes i have a laptop if i need one to use it with.
#2
BOOSTED Vert
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Miami
Posts: 2,307
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I heard that the megasquirt can only do the fuel maps. And you would either need to keep your ecu or use a dizzy. Its cheaper but its a bit more complicated in gettin it tuned as far as I can tell from the software. If I were you I would get another ecu with more support from the people that are actually using.
(Edit for sig violation...CHECK YOUR PMs)
(Edit for sig violation...CHECK YOUR PMs)
Last edited by Aaron Cake; 05-19-05 at 09:10 AM.
#3
323=redheaded step child
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Megasquirt is good stuff. Ive done some custom turbo kits in my day and the megasquirt was one of the better FMU options. Ive toyed with Apexi SAFC's and so on but they arent nearly as good as a megasquirt. Basicly all it does is monitor the 02 sensor...if it reads to rich it cuts fuel a bit if its too lean it increases fuel....very simply but very effective. With SAFCs there is major guess work...
#4
Jesus is the Messiah
MegaSquirt controls my fuel and my ignition.
Do not buy it unless you are willing to learn about it, and programming it for yourself.
It's a DIY ECU. Biuld it yourself. If you have to buy one of those premade kits, Megasquirt is not for you. :O
Do not buy it unless you are willing to learn about it, and programming it for yourself.
It's a DIY ECU. Biuld it yourself. If you have to buy one of those premade kits, Megasquirt is not for you. :O
#5
Jesus is the Messiah
Originally Posted by MARTIN
I heard that the megasquirt can only do the fuel maps. And you would either need to keep your ecu or use a dizzy. Its cheaper but its a bit more complicated in gettin it tuned as far as I can tell from the software. If I were you I would get another ecu with more support from the people that are actually using.
Originally Posted by BIO3M
Megasquirt is good stuff. Ive done some custom turbo kits in my day and the megasquirt was one of the better FMU options. Ive toyed with Apexi SAFC's and so on but they arent nearly as good as a megasquirt. Basicly all it does is monitor the 02 sensor...if it reads to rich it cuts fuel a bit if its too lean it increases fuel....very simply but very effective. With SAFCs there is major guess work...
No, the S-AFC does not monitor the O2 sensor. . . If you are reffering to the megasquirt, you're wrong, it's a true aftermarket ECU, a replacement for the stock ECU, it doesnt "just monitor the O2 sensor" and add or subtract fuel.
S-AFC and MegaSquirt, its not guess work, you can use a Wideband (And/Or a Dyno) with either one.
#6
Full Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 97
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ok well as much as i wish i had time to learn how to program the ecu etc, i only have one car, so i need something that can be installed and running driveable in like a few days. Im pretty good with wiring, and im solid with laptops (and i can read install instructions lol). but i havent ever done anything like this before. I think it would be a cool thing for my car. Since megasquirt seems a bit complicated for me to use, what other system could i use? AEM EMS is like 1300 bux, and greddy emangage is expensive too. Ive heard good things about the Haltech E6K but used there still 900 or so.,
#7
BOOSTED Vert
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Miami
Posts: 2,307
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by MidwestTurboII
ok well as much as i wish i had time to learn how to program the ecu etc, i only have one car, so i need something that can be installed and running driveable in like a few days. Im pretty good with wiring, and im solid with laptops (and i can read install instructions lol). but i havent ever done anything like this before. I think it would be a cool thing for my car. Since megasquirt seems a bit complicated for me to use, what other system could i use? AEM EMS is like 1300 bux, and greddy emangage is expensive too. Ive heard good things about the Haltech E6K but used there still 900 or so.,
Trending Topics
#8
First you have to decide what your plans for the car are. If you want to make some serious power and pretty much forgo any emissions legality (and spend $$$), than start looking at Microtech or Haltech. If you just want to make some decent reliable power without spending an arm and a leg than either an S-AFC or E-Manage would probably work.
I got my e-manage with pressure/ignition/injection harnesses for a little under $400 on E-Bay. Nice thing about the E-Manage is that it still uses the stock ECU, meaning that you can install it and the car will start. (As long as you wired it correctly )
In the end, you have to evaluate you budget and decide from there. If you need a full independant fuel system, then you are likely spending a bunch of money on mods already, so your budget should be fairly open-ended in the first place. What I'm really saying is, be realistic about the performance goals of your car and your ability to reach that with your budget.
I got my e-manage with pressure/ignition/injection harnesses for a little under $400 on E-Bay. Nice thing about the E-Manage is that it still uses the stock ECU, meaning that you can install it and the car will start. (As long as you wired it correctly )
In the end, you have to evaluate you budget and decide from there. If you need a full independant fuel system, then you are likely spending a bunch of money on mods already, so your budget should be fairly open-ended in the first place. What I'm really saying is, be realistic about the performance goals of your car and your ability to reach that with your budget.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Wayne, NJ 07470
Posts: 416
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The MegaSquirt by itself does not do ignition but there are a few Rx7 guys on the MegaSquirt forum who are getting real close to solving the rotary ignition from the stock CAS. They have figured out how to read the CAS, they can do leading ignition and they are very close to getting the trailing ignition.(last time I looked)
Or just use a distributer from a 12A.
There is actually very good support on the forum www.msefi.com (A lot of people think the support is better than most high dollar systems)
But it is DIY. You should be able to splice it in place of the stock ECU and use all the stock sensors. You would need to fabricate a throttle position sensor.
Then you can start tuning...
Anyway, tuning any fuel injection computer is going to be difficult (I would say impossible without dyno time or at least a wideband).
ed
Or just use a distributer from a 12A.
There is actually very good support on the forum www.msefi.com (A lot of people think the support is better than most high dollar systems)
But it is DIY. You should be able to splice it in place of the stock ECU and use all the stock sensors. You would need to fabricate a throttle position sensor.
Then you can start tuning...
Anyway, tuning any fuel injection computer is going to be difficult (I would say impossible without dyno time or at least a wideband).
ed
#10
MegaSquirt Mod
Originally Posted by edmcguirk
The MegaSquirt by itself does not do ignition but there are a few Rx7 guys on the MegaSquirt forum who are getting real close to solving the rotary ignition from the stock CAS. They have figured out how to read the CAS, they can do leading ignition and they are very close to getting the trailing ignition.(last time I looked)
Making it control ignition and read a CAS requires 1) a firmware upgrade 2) build a dual lm1815 circuit (I have schematics) 3) some mods to the megasquirt hardware (adding pull-up resistors, the exact value of resistor to add is something I'm still experimenting with, 1K is too low, 2.2 is too high so there are misses on idle occasionally but above idle works well... tomorrow I'm going to try with a 1.5K resistor; you also have to add a couple of jumper wires, but none of it is very difficult)
There is actually very good support on the forum www.msefi.com (A lot of people think the support is better than most high dollar systems)
But it is DIY. You should be able to splice it in place of the stock ECU and use all the stock sensors. You would need to fabricate a throttle position sensor.
Anyway, tuning any fuel injection computer is going to be difficult (I would say impossible without dyno time or at least a wideband).
The point is that there are people who have gotten tunes they are perfectly happy with and they didn't even use wideband or dyno tune... they just used the butt dyno, and made sure they were reading rich when at high load. I agree the dyno is the best way to go if you want the most power possible.
Anyway, my advice is that if you want to save a lot of money, and do some DIY circuit building (you'll get good at soldering really quick) and wiring... megasquirt is the way to go, otherwise stick with something that's more or less plug 'n play.
Last edited by muythaibxr; 05-19-05 at 02:48 PM.
#11
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Wayne, NJ 07470
Posts: 416
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by muythaibxr
Wrong, Megasquirt works fine with the stock TPS assuming it's working right... we're using it on tofuball's car. Other than that you're correct, you have to splice it into the factory harness or create a new harness.
I also know that I could use the sudden change in MAP instead of a TPS for acceleration enrichment.
ed
#12
MegaSquirt Mod
yeah, some people like MAPdot accel, but I've found that TPSdot works fine for me... You should have 2 TPS's if I'm correct, one of them is kinda like an on-off switch, the other is always in contact. That's how Tofuball's NA s5 is set up.
#13
BOOSTED Vert
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Miami
Posts: 2,307
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by ShadowX
First you have to decide what your plans for the car are. If you want to make some serious power and pretty much forgo any emissions legality (and spend $$$), than start looking at Microtech or Haltech. If you just want to make some decent reliable power without spending an arm and a leg than either an S-AFC or E-Manage would probably work.
I got my e-manage with pressure/ignition/injection harnesses for a little under $400 on E-Bay. Nice thing about the E-Manage is that it still uses the stock ECU, meaning that you can install it and the car will start. (As long as you wired it correctly )
In the end, you have to evaluate you budget and decide from there. If you need a full independant fuel system, then you are likely spending a bunch of money on mods already, so your budget should be fairly open-ended in the first place. What I'm really saying is, be realistic about the performance goals of your car and your ability to reach that with your budget.
I got my e-manage with pressure/ignition/injection harnesses for a little under $400 on E-Bay. Nice thing about the E-Manage is that it still uses the stock ECU, meaning that you can install it and the car will start. (As long as you wired it correctly )
In the end, you have to evaluate you budget and decide from there. If you need a full independant fuel system, then you are likely spending a bunch of money on mods already, so your budget should be fairly open-ended in the first place. What I'm really saying is, be realistic about the performance goals of your car and your ability to reach that with your budget.
The emanage, well, you said it yourself, its a piggy back, which still uses the stock ecu. Which on a turbo car, means you keep one of the most restrictive thing, the afm. Although the emanage is a very good piggy back system and for the price its unbeatable. Definitely better than a safc. But basically, its up to your budget and goals. If its your daily driver then I suggest you either buy an safc or emanage and stick with mild upgrades..
#14
Green Flameless
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: North Central PA
Posts: 2,242
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just got the megasquirt running in my car this past weekend. Honestly, I would not recommend putting in ANY aftermarket ECU if you're going to be limited for time. This is not a job you want to rush because you have to have the car running properly on monday. I can't see how any aftermarket would be any easier. Even if you spent less time on the wiring, you'd still be trying to tune it, which takes quite a while to learn what everything means..
The nice thing about the MegaSquirt is that it has an optional simulator board, where you can make sure everything tests out okay, and learn how changes affect things before you install it, but there's no experience like real experience.
The support is awesome with MS, and the stimulator board is a really nice learning tool, but I still can't see how any aftermarket ECU would be to get set up for a complete n00b in one weekend. I know there's no way I could have done it (this only applies to those of us who have never installed/used a programmable ECU/Fuel controller). I'd be even more wary of using it on a boosted application. If I over-lean, I backfire. If you overlean, you detonate.
Maybe SAFC II is a better choice?
The nice thing about the MegaSquirt is that it has an optional simulator board, where you can make sure everything tests out okay, and learn how changes affect things before you install it, but there's no experience like real experience.
The support is awesome with MS, and the stimulator board is a really nice learning tool, but I still can't see how any aftermarket ECU would be to get set up for a complete n00b in one weekend. I know there's no way I could have done it (this only applies to those of us who have never installed/used a programmable ECU/Fuel controller). I'd be even more wary of using it on a boosted application. If I over-lean, I backfire. If you overlean, you detonate.
Maybe SAFC II is a better choice?
#15
Jesus is the Messiah
Originally Posted by muythaibxr
yeah, some people like MAPdot accel, but I've found that TPSdot works fine for me... You should have 2 TPS's if I'm correct, one of them is kinda like an on-off switch, the other is always in contact. That's how Tofuball's NA s5 is set up.
He has an S4 (87) Therefore he doesnt have the extra wide-range TPS (Used on the S5 to control the OMP), he only has a single narrow range.
#17
MegaSquirt Mod
Originally Posted by Node
rotarygod runs a megasquirt, may want to ask him
also there is a megasquirt message board on groups.yahoo.com
also there is a megasquirt message board on groups.yahoo.com
megasquirt forum
#18
Full Member
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 172
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OK, so this is something I have been wondering about for a little while now: running a megasquirt and stock ECU together, with the stock ECU doing ignition.
So the MS needs coolant temp, air temp, MAP, TPS, and RPM, yes?
So coolant and air temp can be read from the stock sensors by modifying the circuit that reads their resistance, and I think you just assume that the stock ECU uses the same reference voltage
And now some folks here say saying that I can use the full-range part of my S5 TPS to give the MS a signal. Sweet.
RPM should be easy (just 1 wire from one of the coils, right?)
So then, with that in place, should you just be able to cut the wires going from the stock ECU to the injectors, and then run them with the MS?
I am guessing that even if that setup would work, I still can't ditch my AFM, as it affects 6port, vdi, timing, etc? yes?
Someone smarter than me should validate this plan!
So the MS needs coolant temp, air temp, MAP, TPS, and RPM, yes?
So coolant and air temp can be read from the stock sensors by modifying the circuit that reads their resistance, and I think you just assume that the stock ECU uses the same reference voltage
And now some folks here say saying that I can use the full-range part of my S5 TPS to give the MS a signal. Sweet.
RPM should be easy (just 1 wire from one of the coils, right?)
So then, with that in place, should you just be able to cut the wires going from the stock ECU to the injectors, and then run them with the MS?
I am guessing that even if that setup would work, I still can't ditch my AFM, as it affects 6port, vdi, timing, etc? yes?
Someone smarter than me should validate this plan!
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Wayne, NJ 07470
Posts: 416
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, it's a little tricky but you can tap into the sensors that are still feeding the stock ECU and run just the injectors while the ECU controls everything else. However GM sensors are cheap enough to just add in extra sensors. Temperature sensors and TPS can be added or carefully biased to split their signals between both, Oxygen sensor can be spliced between both without any tricks, RPM can be taken off the spark or possibly the ignitor trigger, tach, or CAS signal.
You will lose the stock rev limiter and I don't know what would happen to the ignition if you go too far past the stock rev limit but you can program MegaSquirt to limit at about the same RPM.
And then swap out the other controls as you figure them out. If you like.
ed
You will lose the stock rev limiter and I don't know what would happen to the ignition if you go too far past the stock rev limit but you can program MegaSquirt to limit at about the same RPM.
And then swap out the other controls as you figure them out. If you like.
ed
#20
Full Member
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 172
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
well, I wanted to try and make an minimally invasive install as possible... I got some samples of the connectors on the mazda ECU, and I hope to make up a simple PCB that'll pass through most of the pins, but allow breakout of the the important ones (maybe 10 or so).
The idea being that I can plug my wiring harness into it, it into my stock ECU, and use that to get all the sensor signals and such into my MS, tap power from a fuse, and then the only thing I'll need to route from the engine bay through my firewall is the teeniest little vacuum tube I can find!
Yes, I realize that a bit involved, considering I am trying to use the MS piggybacked for an S5 NA->turbo conversion, but I just really don't want to start cutting up parts of my car....
I'd really like to get rid of the AFM, and should buy a Haltech, but then the car will >never< be "right" again....
And I was going to use a Crane Cams MSD box w/ rev limiter and boost retard to help with the ignition once I add the turbo, BUT now that I think about it, that'll only retard the leading plugs won'it it? and the trailing's will probably start firing way too early.
Maybe this would be easier if I just made up my mind to butcher this car or not....
The idea being that I can plug my wiring harness into it, it into my stock ECU, and use that to get all the sensor signals and such into my MS, tap power from a fuse, and then the only thing I'll need to route from the engine bay through my firewall is the teeniest little vacuum tube I can find!
Yes, I realize that a bit involved, considering I am trying to use the MS piggybacked for an S5 NA->turbo conversion, but I just really don't want to start cutting up parts of my car....
I'd really like to get rid of the AFM, and should buy a Haltech, but then the car will >never< be "right" again....
And I was going to use a Crane Cams MSD box w/ rev limiter and boost retard to help with the ignition once I add the turbo, BUT now that I think about it, that'll only retard the leading plugs won'it it? and the trailing's will probably start firing way too early.
Maybe this would be easier if I just made up my mind to butcher this car or not....
#22
Full Member
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Pasadena, CA
Posts: 172
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can't do that until I raise the $1000 to buy a haltech I don't understand how to do ignition on the MS at all!
Any chance you could give instructions on how to go about using the full range part of the S5 TPS with the MS? here or via PM.... please?
Also, for the injector hookups out of the stock ECU, should I just leave them hanging? or do they needs to be run into a resistor or to ground somewhere?
Any chance you could give instructions on how to go about using the full range part of the S5 TPS with the MS? here or via PM.... please?
Also, for the injector hookups out of the stock ECU, should I just leave them hanging? or do they needs to be run into a resistor or to ground somewhere?
#23
Jesus is the Messiah
Its not that complex, you just plug in the TPS the the TPS input on the megasquirt and calibrate it. Use TPSdot
I'm using the stock injector wiring and everything.
I'm using the stock injector wiring and everything.
#24
Green Flameless
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: North Central PA
Posts: 2,242
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by CrazyDude
Can't do that until I raise the $1000 to buy a haltech I don't understand how to do ignition on the MS at all!
Any chance you could give instructions on how to go about using the full range part of the S5 TPS with the MS? here or via PM.... please?
Also, for the injector hookups out of the stock ECU, should I just leave them hanging? or do they needs to be run into a resistor or to ground somewhere?
Any chance you could give instructions on how to go about using the full range part of the S5 TPS with the MS? here or via PM.... please?
Also, for the injector hookups out of the stock ECU, should I just leave them hanging? or do they needs to be run into a resistor or to ground somewhere?
Long version: There are quite a few people (some on this forum), that are hacking at it to try to get the MS to deal with the stock systems, and it sounds like its close to be solved.
Longer: They're coming out with the Megasquirt Revision II (MS2), that will allow stock timing equipment to be used. The first production batch has been released. The next batch won't go out until the end of july-ish.
You could always do what I'm doing: Use a distributor from a 12a to control your ignition. Not as cool as having control over it, but it will free you from the burden of having to rely ont he stock ECU and wiring to get it up and running, and you can rid of your AFM
I plan on switching back to tstock equipment as soon as the code is stabilized.. I dont' have the time right now to play with it, or else i'd try to figure out how to do it...